Questions? Email
Typical American Food in New York

Typical American Food in New York

Typical American Food in New York

‘Where can I eat typical American food in New York?’ A frequently asked question. First things first, what is ‘typical American food’? Of course, I’ll start with my good old favourites: burgers and pizza. Another very ‘American’ thing to do is eat ‘Southern soul food’, such as barbecue dishes and pulled pork. Besides that, there is the new American cuisine, due to the county’s rapidly evolving food culture. In this top five, I tried to make a selection of restaurants, that represent the American food culture in their own special way.


Going for dinner at Virgil’s Southern-style barbecue restaurant? Order ‘train wreck fries’ as a starter for the table. I know it doesn’t sound too appetising, but trust me. It’s actually a pile of fries, bacon, cheese and other good stuff. I then recommend to choose the pulled pork, truly delicious. Other typical specialities on the menu include the mac and cheese and hushpuppies, for example. They even make their own sauces, you’ll always have about four of them on your table. The interior is spacious and tidy, it’s a great place to visit with (small) children.

The Mercer Kitchen

At The Mercer Kitchen they serve ‘new American’ cuisine. You can go there for burgers, but also a tuna pizza with wasabi, for example. It’s a bit upscale, with a romantic atmosphere due to its underground location. The perfect place for a date! The owner is well-known New York chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten. Just taste his creations once, and you’ll immediately understand why he has become so famous. There is a varied menu, with lots of healthy ingredients and an emphasis on fish- and seafood.


A bit like Virgil’s, only the quality of food is a little lower, and the atmosphere, much better. You’ll find Cowgirl in a quaint street of attractive neighbourhood: Greenwich Village. They’ve selected the decor with the utmost care: it’s like you just walked into a Spaghetti Western, only, they don’t serve spaghetti. They do serve other pasta dishes though, and all with a ‘Western twist’. Mozzarella sticks with bacon and fresh jalapeños and a cowboy steak accompanied by green chillies and sun-dried tomatoes, to name a few. Make sure you save some space some for ‘New York’s best dessert’: baked potato ice-cream. It’s like a baked potato, only the taste is quite different. Let them surprise you! You can visit this place for lunch and dinner. It’s all very low key, you can easily get away with wearing a baseball cap, not a problem at all.

Gotham Bar and Grill

A warning first: Gotham is quite pricey. You’ll easily pay $35 for a main course – something extremely expensive from an American point of view. That’s why this is the perfect place for an evening full of luxury. You’ll get delicious food, prepared by famous chef Alfred Portale. In his restaurant, he serves ‘new American’ cuisine: surprising combinations of traditional ingredients, like his favourites pumpkin, kale (known as a superfood and currently rather hip) and fish.


IHOP makes it into this top 5 as a wildcard. Why? This is a ‘love it or hate it’ kind of chain. It’s not what most would describe as ‘atmospheric’, but it is a prime example of how hundreds of millions of Americans spend their mornings. In this predominantly breakfast restaurant there is a wide variety of different pancakes and syrups. They also serve a fine brunch (after which they’ll have to roll you out of the restaurant) and a ‘lumberjack breakfast’ – the Canadian version of our English breakfast. Oh, they do love strange combinations. I remember eating a steak filled omelette for breakfast, as if it was a kind of taco. Prices are really low. Again: don’t expect any atmosphere whatsoever, do expect an all American experience though – including ‘unlimited coffee’ and ‘unlimited pancakes’ once in a while. Be prepared!

Typical American Food in New York - Cowgirl Typical American Food in NEW YORK - IHOP

You might also be interested in:

Eric's New York Download the free app in the App Store
App store Google play
By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies and the Privacy Policy. Find out more here.

Subscribe to my newsletter

Search tickets
Search tickets